The record in brief
Every established fact, on one page
Trustpilot deleted a review profile that carried a score of 4.9 across 222 reviews, on three working days’ notice, without disputing a single review. Trustpilot had ranked that company 2nd of 24 in a category Trustpilot itself maintains. 196 of the reviews survive and are published here with their original screenshots.
The numbers
| Score on the profile at removal | 4.9 |
| Reviews displayed at removal | 222 |
| Trustpilot’s own category ranking | 2 of 24, Herbal Medicine Store |
| Notice given | 3 working days |
| Reviews Trustpilot disputed | 0 |
| Reviews alleged inauthentic | 0 |
| Policy provisions cited | 0 |
| Reviews recovered here | 196 of 222 |
| Recovered reviews rated below five | 0 |
| Countries represented | 29 |
| Words of customer testimony | 42,579 |
| Recovered reviews also in the company’s own store database | 102 of 196 |
All figures measured 21 November 2026 from the sources listed below.
What the letters said, and what they did not
| The letters state | The letters never state |
| That Trustpilot works only with businesses aligned with its values and core beliefs | Which value or belief was not met |
| That the company is considered a “Bad Fit” | Any policy provision, by name or number |
| That Trustpilot has “sole and absolute discretion” to decide this | Any practice, ingredient, claim, product or page |
| That the domain will be removed within 3 working days | Any dispute with any review |
| That the subscription is terminated immediately | Any allegation that a review was inauthentic |
Timeline
| 2022-05-03 | Internet Archive captures the profile: score 4.9, 95 reviews, Excellent 100%, filed by Trustpilot under Health & Medical > Pharmacy & Medicine > Herbal Medicine Store. |
| 2022-08-16 | A customer reports that Trustpilot removed her review for failing to “verify its authenticity” and asked her for an order email. The review is present on the profile months later. |
| 2023-01-05 | 21:41 GMT. Trustpilot gives notice of removal under its “Bad Fit” clause, citing sole and absolute discretion. No policy provision named, no review disputed. |
| 2023-01-09 | 16:12 GMT. Trustpilot answers the appeal, restating the same standard and adding nothing. |
| 2023-01 | The profile is deleted. Score at deletion 4.9 across 222 reviews, ranked 2 of 24 in Trustpilot’s Herbal Medicine Store category. |
| 2026-11-21 | This record is published: 196 of the 222 reviews recovered from 219 screenshots, each published with its original capture. |
Independent verification
One Internet Archive capture exists: web.archive.org/web/20220503012022/, taken 3 May 2022, eight months before removal. It is outside this company’s control and confirms the score (4.9), the status (Verified Company), the rating spread (Excellent 100%, everything else 0%), and Trustpilot’s own category placement.
All eighteen reviewers visible in that capture appear among the 196 recovered here. The profile held 95 reviews that day; 95 of the reviews recovered here were posted on or before that date.
What is and is not claimed
Claimed: Trustpilot removed this profile on the dates and in the terms quoted, disputed no review, named no provision, and had itself ranked the company 2nd of 24 in its own Herbal Medicine Store category.
Not claimed: that Trustpilot broke a law or a contract; that a pattern of review removals existed (one instance is documented); that the 26 unrecovered reviews were deleted; that any product works. Nothing on this site is for sale.
Sources
Last verified 21 November 2026.